Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (2024)

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (1)

Fall time is winter squash time. Whether you plan to make squash soup, a pie, or pasta, some varieties taste better than others. Here are some of the very best to seek at the market and consider growing in the vegetable garden. Many are beautiful and all have outstanding flavor.

Winter Squash Types

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (2)

Several of the varieties mentioned were bred outside ofNorth America, but all winter squash originate from the New World. Species were first cultivated by Native Americans and developed over thousands of years. There are three primary culinary species known to cultivation—C. maxima, C. moschata, and C. pepo. True pumpkins and acorn squash are C. pepo, butternut squash are inC.moschata, and turban and kabocha squash are in C. maxima.

Across the board, the winter squash on this list rate at the top for flavor, according to countless formal and informal trials and reviews. Gardeners can be confident in choosing any one, if good taste is what they value in a squash. Most are also high performing in the garden.

Kabocha Squash

Kabocha (C. maxima) are squat, orange, greenorgray-green squash that originates from Japan. They have dense, dry flesh that is bright orange. Two of the more common, and nicest tasting are ‘Red Kuri’ (92-100 days) with its orange-red skinned fruits and smooth flesh that is less sweet but nicely flavored, and the gray-skinned ‘Winter Sweet’ (95 days), which has dry, sweet flesh.

Acorn Squash

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (3)

Acorn squash (C. pepo) are wonderfully sweet, deeply lobed, acorn-shaped, and great for roasting. The cream-, gold-, and dark-green-striped cultivar ‘Jester’ (95 days) is just as pretty as it is tasty. Another comparable variety with super sweetness is ‘Sweet Dumpling’ (90-100 days) with its smaller, squatter, ivory and green fruits, and honeyedorange flesh. A less sweet, but colorful, variety is the orange-, cream-, and dark-green-splashed ‘Festival’ (90-100 days). ‘Cream of the Crop’ is a pretty ivory colored variety with good, mild flavor.

Pumpkins

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (4)

One of the finest pumpkins for pie is the tender-skinned C. pepo ‘Winter Luxury’ (105 days). Each year this variety, and the small, piepumpkin ‘Baby Pam’ (105 days), are the pumpkins that I choose for making homemade pie. The‘New England Pie’ pumpkin (105 days) is an old heirloom from the 1800s that is also highly recommended. The unusual, lumpy, blue-gray-skinned C. moschata ‘Marina di Chioggia’ (100 days) is an Italian heirloom turban squash with dense, sugary,orange flesh great for pies, soups, and desserts.

See Also
Solid Starts

Butternut Squash

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (5)

Butternut cultivars are pretty consistent when it comes to flavor. All have richly sweet, nutty flesh favored for all kinds of fall and winter cookery. The compact variety C. moschata ‘Butterbush’ (75 days) is short-vined and bears small butternut squash that aredark orange,dense and very sweet on the inside. Vines are quite productive and early to bear.

Other Winter Squash Types

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (6)

The cream- and green-striped, elongated fruits of Cucurbita pepo ‘Delicata JS’ (100 days) are thin-walled and have sweet, nutty, golden flesh. The small, ornamental fruits of‘Sweet Lightning’ (100 days) look like tiny pumpkins striped with cream. Its sweet, stringless, pale orange flesh is said to be even better tasting than that of ‘Delicata JS’.

Cultivating Winter Squash

Winter squashes need to be started in spring for fall harvest. Be sure to plant them outdoors after the threat of frost has passed. It pays to plant them on berms (click here to read all about berming) amended with lots of organic matter. are recommendedfor spring soil enrichment.
Full sun and space are essential for these sprawling, vining plants. Many may require as much as a 12’ to 15’ patch to grow to their fullest. You will know the fruits are ready to harvest when they are hard, have full color, and their supporting vines start to wither.

Winter Squash Pests and Diseases

There are several pests and diseases that cause squash vines real trouble. Powdery mildew is a common fungal disease that damages leaves and gives then a white, dusty appearance. (Click here to learn how to manage powdery mildew.) Squash vine borers bore into vines and cause them to quickly wilt and die. (Click here to learn how to manage squash vine borers.)

By fall, you should be able to find these squashat farmer’s markets and orchards. You might also consider plantingone or two inyour garden next year.

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard (2024)

FAQs

Best-Tasting Winter Squash – Fafard? ›

Honeynut Squash: The sweetness and flavor made this a clear winner. Delicata Squash: This is actually tied with acorn squash and both are similar in texture and flavor which is why they are ranked at the top.

Which squash has the most flavor? ›

Honeynut Squash: The sweetness and flavor made this a clear winner. Delicata Squash: This is actually tied with acorn squash and both are similar in texture and flavor which is why they are ranked at the top.

What is the best variety of butternut squash? ›

'Waltham' butternut is the dependable standard, but if you'd like to grow a space-saving compact variety, try 'Butterscotch PMR” or “Burpee's Butterbush.” Both have done well for me. The 'Butterscotch' variety of butternut squash was developed by Johnny's Selected seeds and is good for small gardens.

What winter squash tastes like sweet potato? ›

The delicata squash has a moist, creamy yellow flesh that tastes and smells like a blend of corn, butternut squash and sweet potato. It is often referred to as the sweet potato squash. They are best eaten when steamed or baked.

What is the best tasting acorn squash variety? ›

Table Ace Acorn Squash is well-known as the best tasting acorn squash on the market.

What tastes better, butternut or buttercup squash? ›

To make things even more confusing, they actually taste pretty similar: both are often described as having a sweet, nutty taste that goes well with soups (although butternut squash is just slightly sweeter).

Which tastes better butternut or acorn squash? ›

Acorn squash is milder in taste and slightly more fibrous in texture than butternut squash: Its sweet, nutty flavor is additionally muted by the watery character of its flesh. Still, most recipes that call for acorn squash can be made with another members of the squash family, such as Hubbard or butternut.

Which is sweeter butternut or Kent pumpkin? ›

Butternuts are a little sweeter, dryer and can be turned into soups, roasted with cinnamon or put to use in most cooked pumpkin dishes.

What squash tastes like a lemon? ›

Lemon squash are a type of yellow summer squash that are shaped rather like lemons. They're a variant of yellow crookneck squash or yellow straightneck squash, with a similar flavor and texture, and they can be used in the same ways.

What squash tastes like pumpkin? ›

Hubbard Squash

Hubbards are slightly tear-shaped with dark green to pale grayish blue skins and remarkably sweet flesh with a clear pumpkin flavor.

Which winter squash has edible skin? ›

Always: Acorn, Delicata, Honeynut

Wofford and our test kitchen editors will leave the skin on delicata, acorn, and honeynut squash to save time, add nutrients, and reduce food waste. These varieties have thin skins that soften readily when cooked. Next time you slice a delicata into rings ready to roast, don't peel it.

What is the best tasting butternut squash to grow? ›

'Tahiti Melon': Butternut squash variety with a round body and uniquely long necks, almost like a swan. This variety has a particularly sweet, almost melon-like taste. 'Waltham': Pear-shaped butternut squash with light beige skin and fruits weighing up to 2kg.

What is the healthiest squash? ›

1. Butternut Squash. One of the most popular varieties of squash, it can be use in so many ways. It's one of the most rich in Vitamin A, boasting about 100% of the recommended daily value per cup, in the antioxidant form of beta-carotene.

Why is my acorn squash tasteless? ›

I bet you harvested too early. Summer squashes, like zucchini and yellow crookneck, taste best when harvested while they're still small. But winter squashes are different. For best flavor, wait to harvest acorn, butternut, and other winter squashes until later in the season when the rind has hardened.

Which type of squash is the sweetest? ›

Butternut Squash

It is the sweetest winter squash with a thick, bright orange, moist flesh that hides very few seeds. The squash is an elongated pear shape with a thin, pale tan skin that is easy to peel. They usually weigh between 2 and 3 pounds.

Which squash is delicious? ›

Butternut squash

A great all-rounder producing dozens of small fruits with firm, tasty orange flesh that's at its best drizzled with olive oil and then slow-roasted. Sample it in our butternut squash & cherry tomato crumble — an ideal choice for a cosy autumn supper.

What is the best tasting summer squash? ›

Yellow Crookneck

Personally, I think it has the best flavor of any squash I've tried. Both the skin and flesh are very delicate, though, so I find that it doesn't hold up as well as zucchini in some recipes. For that reason, I probably wouldn't attempt to freeze or preserve them.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Neely Ledner

Last Updated:

Views: 6314

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Neely Ledner

Birthday: 1998-06-09

Address: 443 Barrows Terrace, New Jodyberg, CO 57462-5329

Phone: +2433516856029

Job: Central Legal Facilitator

Hobby: Backpacking, Jogging, Magic, Driving, Macrame, Embroidery, Foraging

Introduction: My name is Neely Ledner, I am a bright, determined, beautiful, adventurous, adventurous, spotless, calm person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.